When Heroes Fall
By Rubel Shelly
National news media and personal blogs were clogged with the breaking news last Friday related to David Petraeus. He is the Army general whose leadership had been relied upon by President Bush. He then became Director of the Central Intelligence Agency for President Obama. Brilliant and focused, there are people who believed he was presidential material for the near future.
In the words of Saturday's New York Times, "Few imagined that such a dazzling career would have so tawdry and so sudden a collapse." Some news outlets even pulled up the biblical story of David and Bathsheba as a parallel.
The news story Friday was that Mr. Petraeus had resigned his position as CIA Director because of an affair. The term "adultery" was used in headlines. And the issue of personal morality and public life came front and center again.
The point of this short essay is not moralistic piling-on. David and Holly Petraeus have been married 38 years. Their marriage has survived multiple long deployments, generated two children who are now adults, and was regarded as a model for many in the military. I don't know if they are people of faith. But I can hope and pray for repentance, forgiveness, and reconciliation for the Petraeuses.
The point is, instead, what reactions to the Petraeus story reveal about our moral climate in America. Countless people weighed in to the effect that a sexual affair between Petraeus and the married woman who had written his biography was really nobody's business and should not have required his resignation.
On this point, David Petraeus seems to have been more upright than his would-be defenders. The military code under which he served for 37 years still regards adultery as a crime when it stands to "bring discredit upon the armed forces." Furthermore, an affair is a circumstance that stands to make an intelligence officer susceptible to blackmail.
But the moral atmosphere of our time is terribly polluted. An ongoing poll in the Los Angeles Times asked if an affair should cost someone his career. When I checked the numbers, 75% said it should not. Of course, they did! Movie stars, athletes, clergy, politicians - countless examples can be cited where careers soared with documented infidelities a matter of public record. Some reports say President Obama asked Petraeus to reconsider his resignation. To quote the New York Times again, a "jaundiced Washington" just might have accepted it.
Humans care far too much about our cars and hair, image and options; on the other hand, we can evidence far too little concern about our families and commitments, character and destinies. Something is terribly, terribly wrong with that reality! And this episode has the wrongdoer acting more honorably in some ways than those of us who have heard and reacted to the report.
While praying for the Petraeuses, perhaps all of us should be more aware of our shared identity as sinful people who are vulnerable to temptation.
"If you think you are standing strong, be careful not to fall" (1 Cor 10:12 NLT).
Dr. Rubel Shelly is Pastor of Woodmont Hills Church of Christ, Nashville and authors Fax of Life a weekly service. He is the author of more than 20 books, including several which have been translated into languages such as Korean, Japanese, Portuguese, Italian, French, and Russian. To subscribe to Fax of Life, send email to faxOfLife@woodmont.org